Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Roxanne ✨'s avatar

This is a very interesting piece to read!

As a Muslim, I’ve always felt like those who say music is prohibited or disliked were being a bit extra. Some scholars say it depends on the context, others reject it completely if instruments are used.

Some argue it’s because music can distract us or carry bad meanings, and some even say it can control the mind. I used to think that was exaggerated… until I noticed how people react to songs: “I was fine, then this sad song ruined my mood,” or “I was over my ex, then this song made me text him.” That really hit me.

Whether it’s prohibited/ disliked or not, I think our emotions and actions should be in our hands, not controlled by melodies. It’s okay to enjoy music sometimes if we wanna dance, but not to let it run our mood or become constant background noise.

Honestly, I might be smarter if I listened less 😂 cause when I listen I just zone out and do nothing, instead of thinking. Thank you for writing this, it really made me think. Next time, I’ll leave my headphones in another room!

Expand full comment
sara's avatar

this is powerful. as enjoyable as music can be, it can overpower you and numb you. sometimes we need to let our bodies sit in silence, to take in our surroundings, and use that silence to think hard and to even converse with God. i particularly like the vulnerability here. excellent post!! :)

Expand full comment
64 more comments...

No posts